What if we're on the wrong train?

This article first appeared on Substack November 2026

by Mervin Straughan

What is the deeper message behind the saying: ‘If you get on the wrong train, get off at the next stop’? It’s been popping up regularly on my Facebook, LinkedIn, and Substack feeds.

Often the true meaning of proverbs and sayings lies beneath the surface.

The advice seems straightforward but this train saying points towards several psychological traps that can keep us travelling in the wrong direction: sunk costs and wishful thinking, and, ultimately, a warning about the price of inaction.

 

It might have been the transport theme that resonated. My own Three Bus Journeys coaching model uses bus journeys and an interchange as a metaphor for life. If the current journey isn’t leading anywhere, return to the interchange and plan a new one.

This train saying is more emphatic.

It’s often attributed to Japanese wisdom, but this doesn’t appear to be documented. Nonetheless, it would be wise to heed the instruction because the longer we stay on the wrong train, the more costly it will be in the long run.

Hesitate

There are several reasons why we can be reluctant to abandon a career, a group, a project, a relationship, or a role where we’ve overstayed our welcome.

It might be because we’ve already invested so much effort, emotion, money, and time. Behavioural economist Richard Thaler discussed the Sunk-Cost Fallacy in 1980, highlighting why we might make irrational decisions because of past investments. It encourages us to keep going because we’ve invested so much and come this far.

Sometimes it’s a source of false comfort to believe that because we’re moving, we’re making progress. Doing something doesn’t equate to doing what matters. I’ve been known to take diversions until being forced to take action.

Or, perhaps, wishful thinking tells us the track will somehow curve back towards our intended destination.

The problem is that the price of inaction is not accumulating at a steady pace; it is compounding rapidly. Every mile travelled in the wrong direction is another mile we’ll eventually have to retrace.

There’s also the opportunity cost of the other routes we never take if we remain in our seat.

The dead horse

Not exactly in the same vein, but one of my favourite quotes comes from American clinical psychologist and motivational speaker Dr Bobbe Sommer, whose recordings I used to listen to a great deal commuting to work. She said: ‘If you’re flogging a dead horse, get off the horse.’

The horse wisdom tells us to refrain from unconstructive effort while the train wisdom urges us to take the next constructive action to avoid losing any more time and direction.

Yet, it’s remarkable that some of us prefer the frustration of a familiar situation to the uncertainty of taking action. Such as analysing problems rather than deciding what to do, reviving the ‘horse’ because it cost us so much, tweaking a plan in the hope it will work out, and persisting with a strategy that’s no longer useful.

I’m not blaming anyone. I’ve been there myself and can empathise. It can be draining.

The realisation

Some people stay on the train until a crisis forces them to act. The realisation can be painful.

In those Dr Bobbe Sommer recordings, she described how a breakdown forced her to reconsider her academic and career journey. Until then, she had been studying to become a medical doctor, mainly because she had absorbed the expectations of others and mistaken them for her own ambitions.

Her natural temperament and her career path were not truly compatible, yet she persisted. The pressure mounted, and her body and mind physically rebelled.

Psychological and vocational testing revealed that her interests and strengths lay in understanding human behaviour, not medicine as she had convinced herself. This realisation led to a Ph.D. in clinical psychology and a career as a psychotherapist, corporate consultant, and motivational speaker.

Her experience is recalled in her book Psycho-Cybernetics 2000.

Choosing the stop

Occasionally, the horse asked me what I needed to stop doing. The train asked me what I needed to do next.

This appraisal required honesty no matter how painful. It can be expensive in more than just money to stay on the wrong train.

Experience tells me that if it’s a leisurely toy train in a theme park, then the price of delay might not be too great.

If it’s a bullet train, get off at the next stop.

15 November 2026